The U.S. is taken into account some of the harmful high-income international locations on the planet by which to present start. In the meantime, there is a scarcity of OB-GYNs, leaving greater than 2.2 million ladies of childbearing age dwelling in so-called maternity care deserts with restricted obstetric care.
THE PROBLEM
The “fourth trimester,” or postpartum time-period, is usually a forgotten “trimester” of being pregnant, but performs a essential position in parental, new child and general inhabitants wellbeing, defined Dr. Kristin Leitner, an assistant professor of scientific obstetrics and gynecology at Penn Medication.
“Whereas present process many bodily and emotional adjustments after start, sufferers may undergo problems equivalent to an infection, thrombosis and hypertensive issues, in addition to the brand new onset or exacerbation of psychological well being issues and different continual ailments,” she famous.
“The potential for medical problems postpartum is especially regarding as greater than half of pregnancy-related deaths happen after start; nonetheless, in conventional care fashions, 90% of visits through the perinatal time-period are throughout being pregnant alone.
“Since 2018, the American School of Obstetricians and Gynecologists has really useful that care through the postpartum interval must be an ‘ongoing course of’ reasonably than the standard one-time postpartum go to at 6-12 weeks postpartum,” she continued.
“Even this conventional one-time go to is barely attended by as few as 50% of sufferers in the US, inflicting many sufferers to overlook the chance for early identification of postpartum problems, routine well being upkeep, continual illness administration, and different postpartum objectives equivalent to breastfeeding and contraception.”
This hole between postpartum affected person wants, scientific suggestions and actuality of healthcare entry presents a major problem to sufferers and training suppliers. Modern strategies of figuring out wants and offering ongoing take care of the postpartum affected person are wanted with out added burden to already over-extended suppliers, she added.
“Tragically, non-Hispanic Black ladies undergo maternal morbidity and mortality at charges far above these of the general inhabitants,” Leitner mentioned. “Subsequently, any intervention designed to lower maternal morbidity and mortality should purpose to deliberately goal this inhabitants with acceptable, possible and efficient options focused particularly to this underserved inhabitants.
“Once we piloted a postpartum help program at our hospital – the Hospital of the College of Pennsylvania in Philadelphia – we discovered new mother and father have plenty of questions on their restoration, feeding and child care after start regardless of being given vital numbers of assets within the hospital,” she continued.
These questions have been wide-ranging, equivalent to: Is the swelling in my ft regular? Why is not my child latching? Is my bleeding regular? How quickly ought to I feed my child after their final meal? When will the umbilical wire fall off? The checklist goes on.
“On the time, in 2018, cellular well being purposes had been used for problem-based postpartum help, targeted on particular particular person situations relating to postpartum restoration equivalent to breastfeeding, blood stress monitoring and weight reduction,” Leitner famous.
“Whereas many of those interventions had proven nice promise in bettering compliance with care and lowering healthcare disparities, there have been little to no complete technological interventions to help sufferers holistically through the fourth trimester that present help all through these realms,” she added.
PROPOSAL
In 2018, Penn Medication began its Therapeutic at House program with the objective of utilizing an progressive method to help sufferers throughout their postpartum journey.
“As a part of Therapeutic at House, we optimized affected person workflows on the postpartum unit with the objective to lower size of keep whereas within the hospital after start,” Leitner defined. “We acknowledged, nonetheless, that if we decreased the size of keep, we needed to make sure sufferers felt supported and had a reference to their care workforce after discharge.
“That is the place we began to conceptualize the answer of a cellular, textual content message-based answer,” she continued. “Our hospital had nice success with textual content messages to help postpartum sufferers after discharge within the setting of hypertension of being pregnant (a program referred to as Coronary heart Protected Motherhood); nonetheless, we concluded from a small pilot of roughly 90 postpartum sufferers that to offer holistic help would supply vital complexity to our answer.”
Sufferers wanted extremely complicated and particular person responses to inquiries; as an illustration, about bodily restoration particular to supply mode (vaginal versus cesarean), to care of newborns (diapering and umbilical wire care), and toddler feeding difficulties (ache with breastfeeding, problem pumping and uncertainty with making ready formulation).
“This complexity led us to conclude {that a} ‘easy’ algorithmic method was unlikely to achieve success in offering this inhabitants with the holistic help required,” Leitner mentioned.
So, Penn Medication started working to create a postpartum conversational agent (chatbot) with synthetic intelligence vendor Memora Well being, by which the well being system was capable of leverage pure language processing to offer a conversational expertise for sufferers and layer complicated affected person wants (by affected person sort) onto the expertise.
“First, a steadily requested query financial institution was used to generate correct mapping of inquiries to the suitable responses,” Leitner defined. “Second, surveys (standardized dialog templates designed to gather affected person knowledge) have been created by sufferers’ scientific traits (for instance, breast milk versus formulation fed).
“Third, creation of anticipatory steering particular to affected person scientific traits was deliberate,” she continued. “Lastly, algorithms for doubtlessly acute scientific issues have been designed and layered onto this system. All through this course of we integrated private touches into responses, equivalent to sufferers’ or infants’ names and labored to develop a constant and empathetic tone.”
By offering ongoing contact for sufferers in addition to the flexibility to alert clinicians to affected person issues, the workforce hoped to enhance affected person expertise and outcomes and cut back burden to the care workforce, highlighting for them which sufferers actually wanted direct consideration to a scientific want whereas answering “simple” questions robotically.
MEETING THE CHALLENGE
This system gives textual content messaging that makes use of pure language processing to information postpartum sufferers by their care journey for the primary six weeks after they’re discharged from the hospital. By utilizing automated and conversational textual content messaging to speak with sufferers round routine postpartum care, clinicians can deal with the circumstances which might be extra urgent and require extra complicated medical consideration.
“We realized most of the questions sufferers adopted up with after leaving the hospital have been widespread ones that might be effectively answered,” Leitner famous. “We simply needed to discover that know-how and be certain that it was complete sufficient to offer our sufferers with the identical customized care we ship as suppliers.
“As soon as sufferers go away the hospital, they obtain textual content messages at sure intervals, so that they get steering about what to anticipate for themselves and their child and feeding challenges, in addition to the chance to ask any questions which may come up – it doesn’t matter what time of day or evening,” she continued. “These new mother and father typically have questions concerning the extra typical postpartum actions like once they can return to train, how one can take care of widespread signs equivalent to hemorrhoids, how one can retailer breastmilk, and the newborn’s sleep patterns.”
The AI-enabled know-how permits new moms to ask these questions and obtain clever, customized responses that Penn Medication has helped to tell because the scientific care workforce.
“In different phrases, the know-how is in a position to reply to affected person questions with out them having to attend on maintain or ship a portal message,” Leitner mentioned. “In most use circumstances, they will ask a query by way of SMS and get the suitable response instantly.
“Whereas we after all acknowledge that automated processes generally have kinks, we have made certain to plan for these,” she added. “Our workforce has constructed methods to make sure that responses are precisely reflective of what sufferers anticipate to obtain from their physician.”
A method the workforce has executed that is by schooling with these enrolled in this system, letting them know they’re capable of immediate Penny (the title of the chatbot) to have an actual particular person intervene in the event that they so select.
“In the event that they textual content ‘TEXT ME,’ our scientific workforce will get an alert, and we go into the dashboard to reply again to that particular person manually,” she mentioned. “We additionally created a lot of scientific algorithms to evaluate somebody’s potential degree of want. As an illustration, whereas lower-leg swelling generally is a benign symptom following childbirth, it may also be a warning signal of great problems equivalent to, on this case, postpartum preeclampsia or deep venous thrombosis.
“By means of clinician-developed automated determination tree algorithms, sufferers reply extra questions, which permit clinicians to find out which sufferers with this symptom require extra analysis (equivalent to an ultrasound for a blood clot) and which might be reassured about this widespread postpartum symptom,” she continued.
Not solely does the affected person obtain messaging their constellation of signs is regarding, however the scientific workforce is also alerted by the Memora Well being platform.
“Total, we expect this multi-pronged method, enhanced by AI know-how, is ready to effectively resolve a longstanding downside we have skilled in caring for brand new moms,” Leitner mentioned. “In implementing this software, we have made certain to incorporate affected person suggestions so that they really feel supported all through their total postpartum care journey.”
RESULTS
By means of ongoing coaching of Penny and the underlying know-how, Penn Medication has seen greater than 70% of affected person questions appropriately answered by conversational AI.
“This proportion gave us confidence that sufferers have been receiving well timed, evidence-based solutions to questions on their care whereas lowering the variety of routine questions clinicians must reply to allow them to deal with extra complicated affected person issues,” Leitner reported. “In some conditions, Penny was unable to reply questions as a result of we didn’t have clinician-curated content material for these particular affected person questions, so we have been capable of work with the Memora Well being workforce to develop acceptable responses and optimize this system accordingly.”
Leitner mentioned excessive engagement and affected person satisfaction are main outcomes.
“For sufferers, this system acquired very excessive engagement charges – greater than 98% of sufferers interacted with Penny no less than as soon as, 93% finishing a survey and greater than 52% asking no less than one query – and earned a 92% satisfaction price, displaying this program is simple to make use of and sufferers are getting that customized care they want and deserve,” she mentioned.
“This quantity represents that not solely are we serving to inform the scientific care they want, however sufferers admire and are approving of the instruments we’re utilizing to maintain them wholesome and secure,” she continued. “Importantly, we discovered Black sufferers have been statistically extra prone to promote this system in comparison with white sufferers. As we glance to options for the maternal well being disaster, we should discover applied sciences that particularly goal and help disproportionately impacted populations.”
Leitner additionally mentioned identification of latest onset postpartum hypertensive issues has been a giant plus popping out of using this know-how.
“We began screening our sufferers who had no earlier prognosis of hypertensive dysfunction of being pregnant with our program,” she mentioned. “We’re lucky that in our well being system all mother and father have already got a blood stress cuff to test their BP throughout being pregnant.
“Whereas screening postpartum sufferers, we discovered 3% of sufferers have new onset hypertensive dysfunction of being pregnant, of whom roughly 45% don’t have any signs of elevated blood stress,” she continued. “Along with blood stress screening, making it simple for sufferers to ask questions on signs has additionally allowed us to detect this doubtlessly severe situation.”
Many postpartum sufferers undergo complications on account of fatigue, dehydration and sleep deprivation, however a extreme headache generally is a signal of preeclampsia.
“We have now discovered when a affected person identifies a headache as notably extreme, they typically even have a concurrent hypertensive dysfunction,” she mentioned. “A selected affected person involves thoughts, somebody with a extreme headache who messaged our program. The scientific workforce that acquired this alert was capable of assess the affected person by the platform and detected a severely elevated blood stress.
“She was finally recognized with and handled for preeclampsia with extreme options,” she famous. “After she recovered, she shared this suggestions with us: ‘It helped me, I am a single mother and might’t all the time are available in to see about myself. With out this, I’d have in all probability died,'” she added.
Screening for postpartum despair has been one other side of the brand new know-how that has led to vital outcomes.
“Greater than 40% of sufferers accomplished screening for despair utilizing our platform by way of finishing the ten query Edinburgh Postnatal Melancholy Screening questionnaire,” Leitner reported. “Of sufferers who accomplished this screening, 25% screened as in danger for despair. Detecting irregular screens permits our workforce to attach sufferers again to their scientific workforce sooner for administration, counseling and potential treatment remedy.”
ADVICE FOR OTHERS
When used appropriately, AI can have a profound influence on affected person care, Leitner mentioned.
“As everyone knows, the healthcare workforce scarcity mixed with burnout that so lots of my colleagues expertise poses a hazard to affected person care,” she mentioned. “If there’s a solution to incorporate intelligently designed instruments like what we’re utilizing at Penn Medication, I encourage my friends at different healthcare supplier organizations to take action.”
So long as one has the buy-in of sufferers, in Leitner‘s opinion, there are solely good issues that may come from the flexibility to make use of AI know-how. She gives a couple of items of recommendation for suppliers contemplating utilizing conversational or cellular well being purposes in affected person care:
-
“Earlier than you even begin on this journey, ensure that no matter know-how you are trying to make use of is the one your sufferers are going to have interaction with, as a result of if you do not have the help of your sufferers, the know-how might be ineffective.”
-
“Have interaction the stakeholders on this course of, from the very starting. Utilizing companions or departmental management in your testing section (ask them to ‘assume like a affected person’) can garner pleasure and buy-in from this crucial a part of your workforce.”
-
“In case you are working with a vendor outdoors of your EHR, begin budgeting for and fascinated with requesting integration early within the course of. Failure to take action will make implementation and scale way more troublesome.”
“By automating sure processes, we are able to present extra complete, equitable and efficient care experiences,” mentioned Leitner. “Nobody needs to depart the hospital feeling like they don’t have a lifeline by communication with somebody from their scientific workforce, particularly within the days and weeks after having a child. Instruments like this give sufferers the peace of thoughts, understanding they will ask any query, at any time of day or evening, and get a response.”
Observe Invoice’s HIT protection on LinkedIn: Invoice Siwicki
E mail him: bsiwicki@himss.org
Healthcare IT Information is a HIMSS Media publication.
