Robert Clark is the founder and CEO of Cloverleaf Analytics, a leading provider of insurance intelligence solutions.
In a world hyper-focused on efficiency and speed, the Ethical AI in Insurance Consortium’s recent survey dropped a startling statistic: 80% of mid-size to large property and casualty (P&C) insurers are poised to deploy AI in decision-making within a year. This number isn’t just a trend—it’s a tidal wave reshaping the insurance landscape with profound implications. But how far should automation go? This isn’t a question of whether AI should be utilized, but how to calibrate its role to best complement human expertise, ensuring fairness for all involved.
Recent tech controversies and consumer rights debates have surged in the news, including more states incorporating AI regulations. So, there’s an evident need for industry leaders to embrace automation without losing sight of the personal touch—the soul of our industry—that forms the cornerstone of customer trust and satisfaction. Insurers must remember this while racing to innovate.
Building upon the foundational understanding that AI is transforming insurance, it’s crucial to delve into how AI specifically alters the decision-making landscape in two of the industry’s critical functions: claims processing and underwriting. AI’s influence in these domains is profound, leveraging large datasets to predict outcomes and automate decisions with speed and precision that were once unimaginable.
Particularly in claims management, AI can sift through claims faster, identify fraudulent activity with more accuracy and enhance customer experience by expediting claims resolutions. In underwriting, algorithms analyze myriads of variables to assess risk, determine premiums and identify new product opportunities with customization not previously feasible.
However, although the efficiencies brought on by AI can be significant, the insurance sector must exercise caution not to over-rely on this technology. Human judgment and expertise play an indispensable role. There are subtleties and nuances in insurance transactions, particularly those involving complex cases or special circumstances that algorithms may misinterpret or overlook. It’s in these instances that the human touch becomes irreplaceable. Experienced underwriters and claims adjusters bring empathy, ethical considerations and a level of discernment that AI, at least for now, can’t replicate. Their insight helps ensure that fairness remains at the heart of insurance practices, not solely efficiency driven by technology.
Furthermore, although automation can streamline processes, it shouldn’t lead to a depersonalization of the insurance experience. Policyholders value reassurance and understanding—qualities that AI can’t provide in the same manner as a human. Insurers must remember that at the end of every policy and claim is an individual whose trust in the insurer’s fairness and transparency is paramount. Maintaining this trust requires a careful balance between embracing AI and nurturing the human relationships that have traditionally been the foundation of the insurance business.
Arguably, this integration isn’t an endpoint but a continuous journey. Insurers who succeed will be those who harness AI to enhance their workforce’s capabilities, not to replace them. The goal is to create a seamless alliance between machine efficiency and human empathy, ensuring that policyholders receive not only accurate and prompt service but also feel understood and valued. This equilibrium will be the hallmark of an insurer that has effectively navigated the fine line between AI integration and maintaining the necessary human touch.
Insurance AI innovation isn’t a matter of if but when and how extensively. We’ve dissected the technical prowess that AI brings to the table—from augmenting efficiency to delivering hyper-personalized services. However, our conversation shouldn’t end with technological capabilities; instead, it must pivot to the kind of symbiotic relationship we envision between AI and human insight in delivering insurance services.
The mark of an insurer that’s gone too far with AI and automation in areas that directly impact the insured will be that consumers start to treat their product like castor oil and hurry to find a new carrier. To strike the right balance, we must continuously engage the consumer—our North Star—to gauge not only what they’ll tolerate but what they desire in terms of AI’s role in their transactions. With the efficiency gains and time savings that AI delivers on internal insurer operations, insurance employees should have additional time to cultivate even more meaningful relationships with the insured.
Our sector thrives on trust and personal connection; these are areas in which human judgment and empathy can’t be underestimated. Therefore, businesses shouldn’t unilaterally push the envelope with AI but rather tailor its incorporation to complement and augment the customer experience based on their readiness and appetite for it.
In conclusion, whether you lead an insurance firm or craft policies for one, let this be your call to action: dialogue with your customers. Understand their concerns and what they seek from AI in insurance. Let this intelligence guide your AI integration strategy. This isn’t about selling another product—it’s about responsibly shaping the future of insurance. Build around your customers’ demands and grow with their trust. At the end of the day, it’s their confidence in your services that will dictate AI’s role and your success in harnessing this powerful technology.
Forbes Technology Council is an invitation-only community for world-class CIOs, CTOs and technology executives. Do I qualify?
