AFL grand fianl 2024:

The Swans will console themselves with the fact they were there again. And that is fair up to a point – it is not a failed year to have failed on the last day. Other clubs would happily take getting that far – for a generation of Bombers, finals wins and grand final appearances are just something other teams do. But there’s a difference between being there and turning up. And Sydney didn’t turn up.

John Longmire said after the game: “We’d much rather get into the ring and have a swing than be standing outside looking in. Ultimately, we’ve been able to get ourselves into the position of having an opportunity, and we haven’t got it done today.” Which is true, except Sydney didn’t have a swing.

Loading

Defensively this was as badly as you can play. In a grand final, the Swans played with the intensity of a captain’s run. Taylor Adams, a midfielder of heart and energy, was recruited to the club at the end of last year to add grit and depth but was then once more left sitting in the stands when grand final day came. Adams has his faults as a player, but he is precisely the type of player you want and need in a grand final where the tone is set in the middle of the ground.

Coaches rely on their players to inform their legacy. John Longmire is a good coach, but he has now followed his one grand final win with four losses, and all by big margins. The inevitable review of what went wrong, which must be forensic and unsparing, cannot not look at the coach and ask what he and they could have done differently, as opposed to asking if he is the right person. They need to have the frank conversation with Longmire, and he needs to be frank with himself.

Loading

They knew what to expect from this Lions side. They knew the game Brisbane would play and they offered the Swans no surprises, but Sydney either went in without a plan to combat the uncontested kick-mark game, failed to understand what they were supposed to do about it, or just didn’t execute it. And that comes back to the coaches as well as the players.

In the most basic sense, you can’t hope to beat a game of uncontested marking when you play without energy and desire. But how you can play like that in the biggest game of the year, and for many of those players the biggest game of their careers, is a complete mystery.

Sydney were 10-2 in wins and losses at home on the SCG this year. Does their home ground advantage have a Geelong-like effect of giving them an unrepresentative ladder position? Plainly, the quality of their star players distracted us from acknowledging the weakness of their lesser players. Then, their better players again failed to deliver anything approximating their best on grand final day.

This all sounds like smug hindsight, but that is only because games like Saturday’s provide such clarity about the team and club. Coaches say you learn more from losses than wins, and when they are losses like this you learn a hell of a lot.

The McDonald blunder

The selection of Logan McDonald was clearly wrong and smacked of desperation. Even an untrained eye could tell the player was not right in the first quarter with the ankle he rolled last week.

The Swans assured that he did what was needed to pass the test to play, but all we can judge the decision on is how the player played, and the answer is that he didn’t. He had zero influence on the game.

What could they have done differently if they didn’t pick McDonald? They could have gone back to Peter Ladhams, or they could have just played two tall forwards like virtually every other club does. Yes, that would have been a departure for them but if what you have got is broken, there is no point in persisting with it.

The game was not lost in the Swans’ forward line – it was lost all over the ground – but the absence of anything from any key forward didn’t help. McDonald couldn’t move and Joel Amartey and Hayden McLean were barely more mobile, which didn’t help Sydney’s pressure.

Sydney’s slam Dunk

This is just a reminder that Sydney passed on their father-son access to Josh Dunkley, and he has now won two premierships in teams that defeated the Swans in grand finals– first as a Bulldog in 2016, and then on Saturday as a Lion.

Andrew Dunkley played 217 games for the Swans and so Josh was eligible as a father-son selection for Sydney, but at the time they were not convinced of the need for the big-bodied midfielder given the others they had there. And they had doubts on his kicking, but there was little trouble with his kicking on Saturday.

Dunkley comfortably won his position which – when you consider that position was against Isaac Heeney, the most influential player of the year, the pre-game favourite for the Norm Smith Medal and the man who dominated the qualifying and preliminary finals – is quite the game. It’s reasonable to think the Swans would have found room for Andrew Dunkley’s son in Saturday’s midfield that was pushed around and lacked the strength and desire of Brisbane’s.

To the victors goes an apology

Apologies to Brisbane that this column has focused almost exclusively on Sydney, but when the size of the defeat is so devastating it makes the fallout of the loss so much more significant (and at least there’s no shortage of appropriate gushing in these pages or on these screens for the outstanding Lions’ game).

As opposed to Sydney, Brisbane didn’t have a bad player on the ground. Even Eric Hipwood, playing with dodgy groins, kicked the goal of the game. Hugh McCluggage set the game up, Darcy Fort in his third game of the year ensured it was not lost in the ruck, and Callum Ah Chee was the best player across all the Lions’ finals.

Will Ashcroft still looks like a school boy – a chunky one with bouffant hair, but still a schoolboy – and he played a grand final like it was a school game. And his brother Levi, a probable pick No.1 were he on the free market, is about to join the club for trinkets and baubles in the draft.

Keep up to date with the best AFL coverage in the country. Sign up for the Real Footy newsletter.