While Kellie Lease Stecher, MD, was working as an OB/GYN in Minneapolis, a patient confided in her a sexual assault allegation about one of Stecher’s male colleagues. Stecher shared the allegation with her supervisor, who told Stecher not to file a report and chose not to address the issue with the patient. Stecher weighed how to do the right thing: Should she speak up? What were the ethical and legal implications of speaking up vs staying silent?
After seeking advice from her mentors, Stecher felt it was her moral and legal duty to report the allegation to the Minnesota Medical Board. Once she did, her supervisor chastised her repeatedly for reporting the allegation. Stecher soon found herself in a hostile work environment where she was regularly singled out and silenced by her supervisor and colleagues.
“I got to a point where I felt like I couldn’t say anything at any meetings without somehow being targeted after the meeting. There was an individual who was even allowed to fat-shame me with no consequences,” Stecher said. “[Being bullied at work is] a struggle because you have no voice, you have no opportunities, and there’s someone who is intentionally making your life uncomfortable.”
Stecher’s experience is not unusual. Mistreatment is a common issue among healthcare workers, ranging from rudeness to bullying and harassment and permeating every level and specialty of the medical profession. A 2019 research review estimated that 26.3% of healthcare workers had experienced bullying and found bullying in healthcare to be associated with mental health problems such as burnout and depression, physical health problems such as insomnia and headaches, and physicians taking more sick leave.
The Medscape Physician Workplace Culture Report 2024 found similarly bleak results:
- 38% said workplace culture is declining.
- 70% don’t see a big commitment from employers for positive culture.
- 48% said staff isn’t committed to positive culture.
Toxicity’s ripple effects contribute to several issues in healthcare, including staffing shortages, physician attrition, inadequate leadership, and even suicide rates.
The irony, of course, is that most physicians enter the field to care for people. As individuals go from medical school to residency and on with the rest of their careers, they often experience a rude awakening.
It’s Everywhere
Noticing the prevalence of workplace bullying in the medical field, endocrinologist Farah Khan, MD, at UW Medicine in Seattle, decided to conduct a survey on the issue.
Khan collected 122 responses from colleagues, friends, and acquaintances in the field. When asked if they had ever been bullied in medicine, 68% of respondents said yes. But here’s the fascinating part: She tried to pinpoint one particular area or source of toxicity in the progression of a physician’s career — and couldn’t because it existed at all levels.
More than one third of respondents said their worst bullying experiences occurred in residency, while 30% said mistreatment was worst in medical school, and 24% indicated their worst experience had occurred once they became an attending.
The litany of experiences included being belittled, excluded, yelled at, criticized, shamed, unfairly blamed, threatened, sexually harassed, subjected to bigotry and slurs, and humiliated.
“What surprised me the most was how widespread this problem is and the many different layers of healthcare it permeates through, from operating room staff to medical students to hospital HR to residents and attendings,” Khan said of her findings.
Who Cares for the Caregivers?
When hematologist Mikkael Sekeres, MD, was in medical school, he seriously considered a career as a surgeon. Following success in his surgical rotations, he scrubbed in with a cardiothoracic surgeon who was well known for both his status as a surgeon and his fiery temper. Sekeres witnessed the surgeon yelling at whoever was nearby: Medical students, fellows, residents, operating room nurses.
“At the end of that experience, any passing thoughts I had of going into cardiothoracic surgery were gone,” Sekeres said. “Some of the people I met in surgery were truly wonderful. Some were unhappy people.”
He has clear ideas why. Mental health struggles that are all too common among physicians can be caused or exacerbated by mistreatment and can also lead a physician to mistreat others.
“People bully when they themselves are hurting,” Sekeres said. “It begs the question, why are people hurting? What’s driving them to be bullies? I think part of the reason is that they’re working really hard and they’re tired, and nobody’s caring for them. It’s hard to care for others when you feel as if you’re hurting more than they are.”
Gail Gazelle, MD, experienced something like this. In her case, the pressure to please and to be a perfect professional and mother affected how she interacted with those around her. While working as a hospice medical director and an academician and clinician at Harvard Medical School, she found herself feeling exhausted and burnt out but simultaneously guilty for not doing enough at work or at home.
Guess what happened? She became irritable, lashing out at her son and not putting her best foot forward with coworkers or patients.
After trying traditional therapy and self-help through books and podcasts, Gazelle found her solution in life coaching. “I realized just how harsh I was being on myself and found ways to reverse that pattern,” she said. “I learned ways of regulating myself emotionally that I definitely didn’t learn in my training.”
Today, Gazelle works as a life coach herself, guiding physicians through common challenges of the profession — particularly bullying, which she sees often. She remembers one client, an oncologist, who was being targeted by a nurse practitioner she was training. The nurse practitioner began talking back to the oncologist, as well as gossiping and bad-mouthing her to the nurses in the practice. The nurses then began excluding the oncologist from their cafeteria table at lunchtime, which felt blatant in such a small practice.
A core component of Gazelle’s coaching strategy was helping the client reclaim her self-esteem by focusing on her strengths. She instructed the client to write down what went well that day each night rather than lying in bed ruminating. Such self-care strategies can not only help bullied physicians but also prevent some of the challenges that might cause a physician to bully or lash out at another in the first place.
Such strategies, along with the recent influx of wellness programs available in healthcare facilities, can help physicians cope with the mental health impacts of bullying and the job in general. But even life coaches like Gazelle acknowledge that they are often Band-Aids on the system’s deeper wounds. Bullying in healthcare is not an individual issue; at its core, it’s an institutional one.
Negative Hierarchies in Healthcare
When Stecher’s contract expired, she was fired by the supervisor who had been bullying her. Stecher has since filed a lawsuit, claiming sexual discrimination, defamation, and wrongful termination.
The medical field has a long history of hierarchy, and while this rigidity has softened over time, negative hierarchical dynamics are often perpetuated by leaders. Phenomena like cronyism and cliques and behaviors like petty gossip, lunchroom exclusion (which in the worst cases can mimic high school dynamics), and targeting can be at play in the healthcare workplace.
The classic examples, Stecher said, can usually be spotted: “If you threaten the status quo or offer different ideas, you are seen as a threat. Cronyism…strict hierarchies…people who elevate individuals in their social arena into leadership positions. Physicians don’t get the leadership training that they really need; they are often just dumped into roles with no previous experience because they’re someone’s golfing buddy.”
The question is how to get workplace culture momentum moving in a positive direction. When Gazelle’s clients are hesitant to voice concerns, she emphasizes doing so can and should benefit leadership, as well as patients and the wider healthcare system.
“The win-win is that you have a healthy culture of respect and dignity and civility rather than the opposite,” she said. “The leader will actually have more staff retention, which everybody’s concerned about, given the shortage of healthcare workers.”
And that’s a key incentive that may not be discussed as much: Talent drain from toxicity. The Medscape Workplace Culture Report asked about culture as it applies to physicians looking to join up. Notably:
- 93% of doctors say culture is important when mulling a job offer.
- 70% said culture is equal to money, and 18% ranked it as more important than money.
- 46% say a positive atmosphere is the top priority.
Ultimately, it comes down to who is willing to step in and stand up. Respondents to Khan’s survey counted anonymous reporting systems, more supportive administration teams, and zero-tolerance policies as potential remedies. Gazelle, Sekeres, and Stecher all emphasize the need for zero-tolerance policies for bullying and mistreatment.
“We can’t afford to have things going on like this that just destroy the fabric of the healthcare endeavor,” Gazelle said. “They come out sideways eventually. They come out in terms of poor patient care because there are greater errors. There’s a lack of respect for patients. There’s anger and irritability and so much spillover. We have to have zero-tolerance policies from the top down.”
