Michael Jordan’s 23XI Racing and Front Row Motorsports have joined forces in filing a legal brief to prevent NASCAR from putting a hold on a preliminary injunction.
This court ruling, a preliminary injunction, is vital for these teams as it allows them to keep up their operations as charter teams for the 2025 racing season. The teams’ filing aims to dismiss NASCAR’s request for an emergency stay, following the changes ordered by U.S. District Judge Kenneth Bell in favor of the racing teams.
The legal battle intensified when Judge Bell ruled in favor of 23XI Racing and Front Row Motorsports, granting them the right to use charters from Stewart-Haas Racing. NASCAR was quick to oppose this decision, arguing that Judge Bell misunderstood the rules related to transferring charters. NASCAR moved to file an emergency partial stay, arguing they didn’t have adequate opportunity to explain the complexities involved in charter transfers.
The ongoing lawsuit initiated by 23XI Racing and Front Row Motorsports has placed NASCAR under scrutiny for alleged antitrust violations. The racing teams argue that NASCAR’s charter agreements are designed to monopolize the sport, benefiting a few while suppressing fair competition. Both teams refused to sign a standard charter agreement that was accepted by other racing teams back in September. Within their lawsuit, they accuse NASCAR of acting as “monopolistic bullies” by prioritizing their interests over the racing community’s overall wellbeing.
Logan Riely/Getty Images
Initially, U.S. District Judge Frank D. Whitney rejected the teams’ requests for a preliminary injunction. But things shifted after Judge Whitney was replaced by Judge Kenneth Bell on December 11. Judge Bell sided with 23XI Racing and Front Row Motorsports, allowing them to go ahead with their plans involving charter transfers with Stewart-Haas Racing.
The dispute centers on NASCAR’s charter system, likened to a franchise model, which gives teams guaranteed spots in races with accompanying financial safeguards. The lawsuit tackles the fairness and competitiveness of this system, with the racing teams claiming it restricts growth and competition.
While Judge Bell’s ruling has allowed the teams some leeway, NASCAR is pushing for a stay that could delay these changes until a court further evaluates the situation. If NASCAR’s stay is approved, the injunction will be paused until the Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals makes a decision. However, should the stay be denied, 23XI and Front Row Motorsports can continue with their approved deal with Stewart-Haas Racing.
A court date is set for January 8, 2025, where NASCAR’s motion to dismiss the antitrust lawsuit will be considered. If unresolved, the trial is expected to begin after the 2025 season’s conclusion.
